“There were no Roma witnesses at the Nuremberg Trials”

JVL Introduction

It took until 1979 for acknowledgement that the persecution of Roma and Sinti by the Nazis was racially motivated.  The stories of their experience are few and far between.  It is important not only that their experiences are acknowledged but that they are known, as individuals, as families and as communities.

We also know that prejudice and racism towards Gypsy, Roma and Traveller people continues today, especially but not only in Eastern Europe.  In the UK, the Police Bill threatens to criminalise their whole way of life.

This moving piece by the grandson of a survivor provides a small glimpse into these little known stories.

This article was originally published by Travellers Times on Wed 26 Jan 2022. Read the original here.

“NO ONE NEVER ASKED”

It is the beginning of November, I am calling my grandmother to let her know that I will be visiting Poland soon, and I would like to interview her about the past. She is reluctant. I am trying to explain to an older Roma woman Holocaust Memorial Day and its importance. She doesn`t understand. “Why would someone be interested in Romas and what has happened to us?” she says. I knew I needed to change my approach. I couldn’t use the word interview anymore. “I would just like to talk to you a little bit about travelling in caravans, life back then, how you met grandad”.  I couldn’t see her but I knew she was smiling then. She still misses him.

You pay – she says laughing?

I am broke.

I’ll see you in a few weeks son.

The Roma do not like talking about the Second World War. It is almost taboo. Not many of them are familiar with words such as Holocaust or Samudaripen (a word Roma intellectuals came up with). These words are used in the non-Roma world. Amongst themselves, if they talk about the War they usually say, “during Hitlers time” or “during baro mariben – the big fight”. But they don’t talk about it very often.

Between 1933 and 1945 Roma in Europe were targets of Nazi persecution. The Nazi regime viewed Roma as “asocials.” During World War II, the Nazis and their collaborators killed between 250 thousand and 2 million of European Roma. The discrepancy between the numbers quoted is so great because, it is impossible to know the exact number of Roma population before the outbreak of the war.

Roma were not only killed in the concentration camps. Roma men, women and children were killed inn their caravan camps, in the forests. Whole communities, families were murdered. No witnesses, silently. Forgotten.

A few weeks later I am sitting in front of my grandmother. The tea is as always; way too strong and very sweet.

Why do you want to talk about the past? she cannot believe someone would be interested in what an older Roma woman has to say. Has anyone ever been interested in us – she adds.

I am starting with a very simple question: what is your name? Sabina Rybicka.  How about your Roma name? – Incioro. Yes, Roma have two names. Official for admin purpose. That’s a name for the non-Roma world and Roma name. The one they are attached to more.

How old are you? She laughs a bit. Not because you shouldn’t ask a woman about her age but because she simply doesn’t know. “I am old but I do not know how old I am” She was born in a caravan camp. Somewhere in woodlands. Somewhere in Poland. It must have been before the war and she was told that it was around harvest time. Like many Romas, she never went to school. She says that life was the best education although sometimes you need to repeat “ a lesson” a few times before you learn it.

Tell me something about the past, something you remember – I ask her.

I had a big family. A lot of siblings, uncles, aunties. Our camp was made of over fifty caravans.

We travelled from spring to autumn. From one place to another across Poland. We would rent a house during winter from the Poles, but once it was getting warmer, we were on the road again.  Before The war, my dad was a horse trader. He was very well known and respected. Our caravan was stunning. It had floral paintings all over it and wooden dragon statues; you know; to protect us from bad luck. I remember us kids playing in the forest. Women would take care of their families. They would cook, and do laundry in the river. A lot of women were fortune-tellers. They told fortune to the Poles, not for money, but for some food. Evenings were the most beautiful. A lot of singing and dancing around the bonfire. Older people told stories about ghosts and old fairytales. We kids would sit and listen, eating together from one plate. Then everything changed.  She is silent for few minutes.

We were captured in the forest. My whole family. That one day changed everything. I was a little girl and I did not understand what was happening but I knew that there was something bad going on.

It is dark. The air is heavy. It has to be like that when a lot of people are stuck for days in a closed train carriage. The stench of sweat, faeces and fear. There is no air. People are dying. I am scared. Someone told us that we are being sent to Russia, Sibir. I didn’t know what it means but soon I was to find out that.

The first thing that comes to my mind when I think about that time is hunger. That and cold. I cannot remember how long we were there. Days turned into weeks and months. Maybe years? Every day looked almost the same. You just get used to it. Apart from one thing; your relatives dying or being killed. One never can get used to that.

We had to work very hard for no money. Maybe the remuneration was staying alive? Men worked the hardest. Physical work in the forest. Sometimes we would get some food but that was not every day. Women had to work as well. My mother did not have shoes. Her feet froze and eventually had to be amputated. Sometimes I would sneak out of the camp, which was not heavily guarded and go to a village and beg for some bread. We all learnt new words: tuberculosis, scarlatina, dysenteric, typhus.

I can see she is getting tired. There are things she doesn’t want to talk about.

She stands up and goes to a wardrobe. After a few minutes, she comes back with a little bag wrapped in a white kitchen towel.

We managed to come back to Poland. Those of us who still were alive. It was still the war. We were hiding in forests. Our caravans were not anymore colourful or big.  We did not want to be visible. Instead of fifty caravans now there were just a few. It felt lonely.

Your grandfather Ludwik’s tribe was still travelling around this time. From what I know – it was a pretty big camp. Around sixty people They just arrived at a new place. His father at this time was in Auschwitz. Ludwik was sent by his mother to a neighbouring village just to see what was there. When he was about to come back to the caravan camp, some Poles stopped him and said not to go there because the Nazi ambushed the caravan camp. He tried to run away but they forced him not to go. When eventually he got there, the whole caravan camp had been murdered. His mother, his siblings – everyone. All killed by the Nazi. The Poles were burying them.

He said once that the air had a scent of death.

Many years later he tried to go back there. To pay his respect. Sometimes we would get close, but then he would stop and say: I cannot do it. He never went there.

My family was still hiding but we were captured again.

My grandmother then started to unwrap the little package, in the white kitchen towel, that she had retrieved from the wardrobe earlier. Inside the bag is some old documentation.

This is my ghetto ID. I have no words to describe how it was there. Again hunger, biting up. People dying all around. One loses hope. A lot of people tried to escape. Some succeeded but those who were caught were killed straight away. Two of my sisters died in the ghetto. A lot of my family members died there as well, and in concentration camps. Some of us survived.

Roma Ghetto ID cards

There were no Roma witnesses at the Nuremberg Trials.

Only in late 1979 did the West German Federal Parliament identify the Nazi persecution of Roma as being racially motivated, creating eligibility for most Roma to apply for compensation for their suffering and loss under the Nazi regime. By this time, many of those who became eligible had already died.

Have you ever spoken about that gran?

No, no one ever asked.

 

Szymon Glowacki (he/him) is the Stronger Communities Outreach Lead at Protection Approaches – a charity working to prevent identity-based violence in the UK and worldwide. Szymon develops, delivers, and leads workshops with communities and schools, including Protection Approaches’ annual Holocaust Memorial Day workshops with students across London. Szymon has worked for the past 10 years with Roma-Gypsy communities in Poland and the UK, and was himself born and raised in Poland to a traditional Roma-Gypsy family. Learn more about Szymon’s work on twitter at @IBVprev.

 

Comments (12)

  • Teresa Grover says:

    Everytime I read something new about the Nazis hatred of human beings my heart hurts.
    The first time I was taught about this shameful human episode I was 18, leaving school .
    The school had arranged for school leavers to go to Stoke Dabanon, a contry house & grounds & each day we had lectures about a variety of subjects. Photographic & film history about concentration camps & all the horrors of pits of dead bodies thrown into pits of lime!
    The mountain of shoes, clothes, personal belongings. Boxes of wedding rings, gold teeth even lampshades & book covers made of human skin….
    Those photos, films have remained in my head since I was 18. I’m nearly 74 now.
    Every single school everywhere should show young people exactly what humans are capable of. The hatred that causes these barbaric horrors that divide the pure white & blonde to the dark haired.
    The healthy to the deranged mentally ill, to the disabled physically, the gays who were born gay.
    Yes people must SHOW THOSE HORRORS because they are beyond belief.
    No one should be allowed to hate, torture, starve & discriminate . NO ONE. I weep at the horrors people still inflict on others in 2022.

    0
    0
  • Harriet Evans says:

    Thank you JVL for posting this article about the Roma as a target of Nazi racism. More need to know about this

    0
    0
  • John Noble says:

    Considering we are all “Out of Africa” it is dismaying that we hate each other just because of some perceived difference in culture or skin tone, both of which are dependent on the part of the earths surface we reside upon. Considering the so called size of the human brain is it not time we stopped believing the fairy stories our leaders tell us to make us fear each other, this fear being sufficient for us to kill our neighbours babies.

    0
    0
  • Stephen Richards says:

    Roma & Sinti culture is unwritten. Reading & writing is usually taught in schools but life on the road excludes this luxury as all knowledge must be practical & relevant to a hand to mouth existence. These are the most persecuted people throughout western European history; with no claim to a homeland of their own, they belong nowhere, not wanted. The Porajmos has no significance in western culture.

    0
    0
    • Leah Levane says:

      thank you – important to note that there are many highly educated Gypsies, Roma and Travellers but it is true that for a long time history was conveyed orally (or not so much as this piece outlines) – it may be a small part of the reason why we know so much less about their experiences of oppression but the evidence is there.

      0
      0
  • patrick lonergan says:

    Shocking piece of Hidden history. Thank you .

    0
    0
  • Julia says:

    Thank you for this moving article, all the more timely because of the vile Patel’s Police Bill. I am called overly dramatic or ridiculous when I say England is becoming a fascist state, but are the measures in that Bill, particularly regarding Gypsy, Roma and Traveller communities anything but fascism?

    0
    0
  • Jean Crocker says:

    Thankyou for thus

    0
    0
  • Naomi Wayne says:

    Thanks for posting this article, a piece both incredibly beautiful in the writing, and heartbreaking in its content. Individual Jewish victims’ response was not that different: shame, repression of appalling memories, determined silence. The difference is that at the more public level, the community suffering of European Jews is widely known, and, because of obsessive Nazi documenting, pretty accurately recorded. I reckon this puts a special obligation on Jewish people and organisations to reach out to Roma communities and offer to help record their experience and try to narrow that incredible gap between numbers murdered, between a quarter of a million and two million.

    0
    0
  • Amanda Sebestyen says:

    When the Roma from former Czechoslovakia came to the UK in and after 1997, I became aware of two families who had survived Auschwitz. Many others were killed in different ways, as Szymon Glowacki records. Only a few hundred Czech Roma survived, so most of the refugees who came here were from surviving Slovak Roma families with a different WW2 history: being driven out of their homes to starve and live as outcasts, then having any caravans destroyed once a communist government took over.
    The Bock family had a unique story to tell, as they were Sinti who travelled with their horses between Germany and Bohemia in the Czech lands. Their deaths are recorded in the Auschwitz Book of the Gypsies, to be found in the Wiener library. Several took part in the Resistance; one uncle was executed in Prague Castle and another was sent from Auschwitz to Natzweiler (the only camp on French soil, and specially built to imprison resisters: from across the Reich: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natzweiler-Struthof_concentration_camp

    This uncle may have been among the able-bodied men separated from the ‘Gypsy Family Camp’ at Auschwitz after they successfully fought off the SS’s first attempt to burn everyone in that camp and clear it for the Hungarian Jews to come and be killed in their turn. On 2nd August 1944 the SS returned and exterminated the remaining families, this is now the date of the Roma Genocide Memorial Day.
    Vilem Bock had a huge story to tell, as a child of very few suvivors. With the human rights lawyer and Czech-language scholar David Chrico, and the researcher-author Nidhi Trehan https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv18gfz6v
    I arranged for the Bock family to be interviewed. I was glad that the Holocaust Memorial Trust did not hold back on showing how terribly the family had also been treated once they had reached the UK and asked for asylum. The family moved to Canada after Brexit. You can read their story here: https://www.hmd.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/the_history_of_the_bock_family.pdf

    0
    0
  • Joanne Pearce-Timmins says:

    My paternal grandfathers family were Spanish Roma and my Maternal fathers family were White Russian. Dads father never spoke of his family neither of them spoke of the families they left behind when they fled. I will never know how many of my collective family died by Hitlers orders

    0
    0

Comments are now closed.