Roma from Ukraine are in need of support
JVL Introduction
In this briefing for the Institute of Race Relations, Tony Booth reports on his conversation with Miroslav Klempar about the discriminatory response to Ukrainian Roma refugees when they arrive in the Czech Republic.
Miroslav Klempar, himself Roma from Ostrava, compares gradations of discrimination between Poland where Roma are ‘at least treated as humans’ with the inhuman conditions offered in the Czech Republic, particularly in Brno.
Anyone who can contribute to a network of support for Ukrainian Roma coming to the UK, is asked to get in touch.
This article was originally published by Instutute of Race Relations on Thu 23 Jun 2022. Read the original here.
Roma from Ukraine
On 10 June, Tony Booth, Environment Officer with Jewish Voice for Labour, talked to Miroslav Klempar, a Rom based in Ostrava who works with Awen Amenca which is involved in supporting Roma arriving from Ukraine.
Miroslav is particularly concerned about the treatment of Roma arriving from Ukraine in the Czech Republic. It is no surprise that they face severe discrimination on arrival, are separated and given harsher treatment compared to non-Roma (who Miroslav refers to as white Ukrainians). It was in the Czech education ministry that a senior civil servant responded to Tony’s question – ‘why do you continue to segregate Roma into separate (special) schools?’ with ‘families will not tolerate having vermin in their schools’.[1]
Miroslav contrasted the discriminatory treatment of Ukrainian Roma in Poland (where ‘at least they are treated as humans’) with their treatment in the Czech Republic. He observed when he was passing through Krakow, that Roma arriving at the station were offered tea/coffee and nappies for babies. While some Roma are provided with accommodation in the Czech Republic, this is generally in a dilapidated state and has to be improved to make it habitable. But many are being kept in tented camps.
Conditions differ markedly between cities. In Ostrava, 150 families are housed in an old detention centre surrounded by high walls and barbed wire: it is ‘like a prison’, although they have been given beds, food and water and have relatively adequate toilet and hygiene facilities. But in Brno, there are 200 Roma in tents with no flooring – so people are sleeping on sometimes wet mud. There is very little food, and the water supply is poor. There is nowhere to boil water to prepare food for babies. The toilet facilities are inadequate and have ceased to function. There are police with dogs, behaving brutally. An official from the district magistrates’ office of Brno visited and blamed them for the poor living conditions. The official said that if they don’t return to the Ukraine, their children may be taken away from them – this is terrorising people. Some have returned to the Ukraine to face the war, while many are completely stuck with no money.
An open letter from eleven Roma organisations calls for better conditions.
Miroslav referred to a particular issue about Ukrainian Roma who are Hungarian citizens. He described a peculiar anomaly of the Victor Orbán regime in Hungary which ‘at one point offered Hungarian citizenship to non-Hungarians’, and a number of Ukrainian Roma – around 4 percent – took up the offer. So there is particular pressure on these Ukrainians to go to Hungary. But perhaps the fact that they have Hungarian passports may give other opportunities to travel – and get support in the UK, for example.
Czech and UK networks for Roma
Among the organisations supporting Ukrainian Roma, Miroslav mentioned Agape, Romodrom based in the Czech Republic, as well as the Roma community organisation he works with, Awen Amenca. He said Christian Aid was also actively involved. In the UK, he mentioned the network around Europe Roma, and the Compass group, based in Peterborough, who are ‘working with marginalised and migrant communities’ to support integration. Compass’ chief executive is Petr Torák MBE, a former police officer in the Cambridgeshire police and an honorary consul for the Czech Republic. His position did not prevent discriminatory treatment when, on a recent visit to Prague, he was refused service in a restaurant because he is Roma.
What is needed
Ukrainian Roma need help in different ways, and one of the things that Tony and Miroslav agreed on is to clarify how best to contribute. People need information on current visa requirements and immigration and asylum rules, since arriving to the UK without a visa is likely to lead to deportation. While people in the United Kingdom may be aware of these requirements, it is clear that some supportive Roma in the Czech Republic are not.
To enter the Czech Republic, Ukrainian citizens are not required to have a visa, but they need the ‘confirmation of temporary protection’ to access help dedicated for refugees.
Tony is keen to find out:
- How many Ukrainian Roma have come to the UK on the government scheme to support Ukrainian refugees?
- How can this number be increased through creating networks of sponsors, supporting the application process to obtain visas and making sure that essential financial support is in place?
- How is it best to send assistance to Ukrainian Roma at present in the Czech Republic and what form should it take?
Related Links:
Anyone with information or ideas to contribute to the network of support for Ukrainian Roma should contact Tony Booth on environment@jvl.co.uk
[1] Tony and Miroslav have worked together over several years as contributors to a Council of Europe project on overcoming Roma discrimination within education in a number of countries (Czech Republic, Slovakia, Romania, Hungary, Bulgaria, although the last two countries pulled out for reasons connected to Roma discrimination)
Sometimes I don’t like humans.
So grateful that this story is coming out. Not only the Czech Republic but Poland, Moldova and all the border countries are treating the Ukrainian Roma refugees disgracefully. Not forgetting our own government! Roma families have now been sent to Ireland because the UK has put up so many obstacles. The Europe-Roma organisation , based in Birmingham, has 50 families lined up to come here and landlords with accommodation for them. Ladislav Balaz, the Chair of Europe-Roma, has been to the Czech tented camps and also the streets and railway stations where the Roma refugees from Ukraine are trying to survive. He is due to return there next week and is sending out an appeal for support. Please send donations to: Account Name: ERN. Sort Code: 20 09 03. Account No: 63414183. For further information and reports write to Ladislav Balaz at europeroma.eu.uk@gmail.com
Congratulations to JVL issuing a ‘live news account’ that has not been first mediated by ‘the Guardian’. Roma & Sinti are not the only nomads with a history of persecution in Europe but they have throughout history, been kept invisible. ‘Gypsies’ have always been the forgotten people who do not belong & therefore shunned by the respectable bourgeoisie.
This is still happening & examples can be found closer to home as this Tory government passes legislation making ‘the travellers’ lifestyle’ illegal. Gypsies are the most persecuted people in history but this will not be documented, as the culture is predominantly oral & not written.
Bradford has welcomed maybe 5000 Slovakian Roma in the last decade who are now Bradfordians. I know personally how viscerally racist Czechs and Slovaks can be against Roma. It’s disconcertingly shocking. I will try to find people here who might be able to assist.