Paddington Bear in the struggle against deportation

A fake deportation notice that’s part of a protest from civil servants against the Home Office’s Rwanda policy: Twitter

JVL Introduction

THE Government’s “offshoring” policy “should shame us as a nation”, the Archbishops of Canterbury and York and 23 other bishops, have said.

It received a major setback yesterday when the first flight of people due to be deported to Rwanda was halted at the last minute following the intervention of the European Court of Human Rights.

Opposition to this dreadful policy is widespread as this story about dissent within the civil service shows.

And where were Keir Starmer, Angela Rayner, Anneliese Dodds, Lisa Nandy, David Lammy, Jess Phillips and another 7 Labour front-benchers who didn’t sign Clive Lewis’s letter to Priti Patel, protesting about another deportation flight, to Jamaica?

This article was originally published by the Guardian on Mon 13 Jun 2022. Read the original here.

We are the civil servants who put up ‘Go home Paddington’ notices in revolt

The Rwanda deportation plan has pushed us over the edge. So we are resisting, and invite our colleagues to stand up for their principles

Like many civil servants, I joined because of the principles. We work here because we want to serve the public, to make vital services work well, and to help people. I work with dedicated, skilled and compassionate people. We understand that we aren’t the politicians; we just want to get on and make things work for the public.

But at the Home Office, it is unavoidably clear that the things we are now ordered to put into place – from borders to policing to immigration enforcement – are doing real harm to many people. As the report on the historical roots of the Windrush scandal showed, the Home Office has a long and ugly history of structural racism, with UK immigration policy shaped for decades to try to minimise the number of black and minority ethnic people in this country.

So it is little surprise that the barbaric Rwanda transportation plan – to forcibly fly people who have escaped trauma and horror to another continent – is presented to us by senior fellow civil servants as “humanitarian”. The laughably absurd idea that it has anything to do with preventing people smugglers is repeated with a straight face.

If the racial priorities in our work weren’t clear enough from the Windrush scandal, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has rammed the point home. Of course, innocent people bombed out of their homes must be offered help and a place to rebuild their lives if they choose to. Yet this is hardly the only war going on. The difference in response when there are white faces involved couldn’t be more stark. Whole new visa routes were created with vastly more “generous” conditions, such as not being banned from working or accessing vital public funds.

Ukraine, like Covid, has shown some glimpses of how the government can rouse itself to care for people and support lives – but only sometimes. Why has this kind of response never happened for the people in desperate situations in Yemen, Ethiopia, Sudan, Palestine, Afghanistan? Let alone the climate crisis.

Time and again we have seen official leadership so unable to demonstrate basic humanity that those of us in the regular ranks look at each other and shake our heads. Can this really be happening? Is this who we are?

Eleanor Tomlinson, from East Yorkshire, was inspired after watching the recent Jubilee celebrations featuring Paddington having tea with the Queen

So, we say: enough.

We’re tired of accepting that things have to be this grim. Tired of quietly going along with every new step we are told to take into an ever more controlling, more divided world. We’re sold a beautiful dream of an organisation that has learned from Windrush – “One Home Office” is the name of the department’s transformation programme. But if we really are to become ‘One Home Office’, we need to play our part.

Welcome to “Our Home Office”, a growing network of civil servants employed by the Home Office who take our principles seriously. Such as impartiality and fairness and respecting the rule of law for everyone, and upholding the rights that every person has.

And we are finding ways to put these into practice ourselves. In what we do, and what we resist. In speaking out. In listening in, to voices often disbelieved or ignored. In finding whatever cracks we can in the stifling, inhuman, bureaucratic walls, prising them open to make space to build something better. We speak to colleagues and share our support, we act however openly or subtly we feel we can – from posters reminding colleagues of our true values, to the “Refugees Welcome” stickers we are placing in our buildings. We are trying to find a way to live by and act on our principles.

Maybe, somehow, this hostile environment that entangles all of us can be disarmed, unwound. And we invite our fellow civil servants: which strands will you help untie?

Comments (3)

  • Carmen Malaree says:

    This article gives me hope. Some structures of government can take positive action against xenophobic, racist policies put forward by this awful government. How much longer are people having to put up with voices from ministers defending the indefensible?

    0
    0
  • Paul Wimpeney says:

    Bravo civil servants!
    So hierarchical is British Society that we have built ladders into everything; class, of course, first and foremost, gender, ethnicity and now identity of the enemy of those requiring sanctuary, unless the ethnicity quotient is a significant counter-factor.
    So, Ukrainians find their flag everywhere; football authorities who fined Glasgow Celtic for permitting a Palestinian flag to be waved in their ground now encourage the players to have a Ukrainian flag each as they enter the arena. Of course, Ukrainians have skin that is reassuringly white and some even have blond hair. If only Afghans were a little paler, because in other ways, they would score quite well. Yemenis don’t stand a chance: Saudis buy an awful lot of weapons!
    The Government reaches for a cast-off Israeli policy – the base of a late twentieth century genocide, the most densely populated African country.
    And to show that we have not lost our sense of irony, the Home Secretary forcing through the policy is the daughter of an immigrant from Uganda – just next door.

    0
    0
  • Graeme Atkinson says:

    Good ‘ole Paddington.

    0
    0

Comments are now closed.