Why settler pogroms are now sweeping the West Bank

A field burns amid a series of Israeli settler attacks on Palestinian communities in the occupied West Bank, near the Palestinian village of Qusra, June 22, 2023. (Flash90)

JVL Introduction

It is difficult to find words to describe the reality in the West Bank today.

Jewish settler terrorism is so rampant that the heads of the Israeli security establishment have labeled the pogroms as “terrorism”. Palestinian civilians are becoming the central target, rather than merely acceptable collateral damage.

What we are witnessing is in part a struggle between the “official” security forces and the frustrated extremist settlers not over the goal – the steady erosion of the Palestinian presence in the land of Palestine – but over who should set the pace.

The goal in both cases is the elimination of a collective Palestinian identity. A genocide is taking place while governments everywhere sit back and allow it to happen.

Where, you may ask, is Labour’s voice calling out this ongoing, brazen violation of international law. The silence is deafening.

This article was originally published by +972 Magazine, In partnership with Local Call on Mon 26 Jun 2023. Read the original here.

Why settler pogroms are now sweeping the West Bank

Frustrated at the military’s pushback to their pogroms, settlers will continue upholding Jewish supremacy by any means necessary.

Sometimes there is an event so extreme that it tears the veil of willful ignorance from the eyes of Jewish-Israeli society. The pogrom in Huwara last February, in which hundreds of settlers torched the Palestinian town in the occupied West Bank, was such an event. Last week’s pogroms in Turmus Ayya, Urif, and Umm Safa raised the curtain even higher, forcing many Israelis to stare straight at a reality that has long been present and can undoubtedly get worse.

But the main problem is not in the byproduct of occupation — Jewish settler terrorism — but in Israel’s routine activity in the territories. Indeed, the decision by the heads of the Israeli security establishment to label the pogroms as “terrorism” indicates that the veil has only been partially lifted; they simply don’t want Jewish terrorism to interfere with or embarrass the authority of the army, Shin Bet, and police.

Settlement is itself a violent act, whether it is done in concert with Israeli law or with the law following retroactively. It is violent because the settlers impose their presence on the natives and rob them of land, water, free movement, and basic human rights. It is an organized system of violence on behalf of the state.

Subscribe to The Landline

+972’s weekly newsletter

The symbiosis between the army and the settlers is not limited to violence; it also exists in the understanding of their mission. The settlers explicitly define their mission as the Judaization of the area, and they do this effectively and consistently. The army’s mission is not to provide security for all residents in the territories — as international law requires of the occupying power — but rather to protect the settlers from the reactions of the native Palestinians, who are not allowed to defend themselves, neither with the help of the Palestinian security forces, nor by establishing their own national guard. The factor that determines whether a West Bank resident’s life and property will be protected is whether or not they are Jewish.

Expanding settlements as a response to the murder of Israelis — as senior government ministers pledged to do last week — is also not a harmless civil action. It is violence without immediate bloodshed, yet which will inevitably engender Palestinian resistance, followed by bloody army repression.

The Palestinians are tolerated only if they assimilate into the landscape, becoming inanimate objects that forgo their collective identity. But as long as they maintain that identity, they are by definition an enemy. The army and the Shin Bet will continue to control them with biometric and electromagnetic data that tracks their location, actions, and thoughts as expressed in phone calls and on social media. The Palestinians’ complete dependence on Israel for permits makes it easy for Israeli authorities to gather information about their family and medical conditions, sexual tendencies, personal weaknesses, and social structures, and to weaponize that information to force them into collaboration.

Jewish supremacy is clear as day, and the Palestinian people are bleeding physically and politically. However, as settlements expand and the army operates, the friction increases, and so too does the Palestinian motivation to react. Today, Palestinian violence has little expectation of liberating the West Bank; the power disparity between the parties is all too evident. Rather, it is intended to exact a price, any price, from the colonizers.

Dangerous frustration

This pushback frustrates the settlers. How is it possible that all their power and supremacy has still not erased Palestinian identity and resistance? That frustration is what drives pogroms like those we saw last week, which then pushes the army and government to use even more force to expand the settlement project. Just a few days ago, Col. (Res.) Moshe Hagar, head of the pre-military academy in the settlement of Beit Yatir, called for the destruction of a Palestinian city or village in order to teach the Palestinians a lesson. Meanwhile, Bezalel Smotrich, who serves both as finance minister and minister in charge of the civilian affairs in the West Bank, called any comparison between what he termed “Arab terror” and the “civilian counter-operations” both “wrong and dangerous.”

Damage caused to Palestinian homes and cars by Jewish settlers in the West Bank town of Turmus Ayya, June 21, 2023. (Nasser Ishtayeh/Flash90)

Their frustration today is greater than it was in the past. In the 1980s and ’90s, the settlers in the occupied territories transformed from a civil movement supported by the establishment into the establishment itself. They found their way into the executive levels of the government’s civil and security branches that control the Palestinian population and their land. Today, under the current far-right government, they have reached the height of their powers. They do not think for a moment about acknowledging the limitations of their power, because the vector of their political ambitions is linear and unequivocal. They must not retreat.

The idea of containing the conflict in order not to lose control — as the army, Shin Bet, and police are hoping to do — is unacceptable to those whose frustration is on par with their political and theological extremism. The settlers are pushing the security establishment to act in accordance with Hagar’s vision. Unlike in “Operation Defensive Shield” — when the Israeli army physically and politically destroyed the Palestinian Authority in 2002 through devastating urban invasions — today there is no leadership left to decimate. The PA under President Mahmoud Abbas has already done this in the service of Israel. The Israeli right’s call to launch “Defensive Shield II” is instead a call to action that places Palestinian civilians as the central target, rather than as mere acceptable collateral.

The end of the conflict and the two-state solution are no longer relevant to the Israeli public and the international community. Lacking a solution — or more accurately, the will to pursue one — foreign governments, including Arab states, have allowed Israel to create a single regime in the entire area between the river and the sea without having to officially declare annexation.

The fact that two different groups live under two sets of laws under a single sovereign means that Israel is implementing practices of apartheid, racial supremacy, and military rule not as a matter of foreign policy, but rather as its domestic policy.

This is why, for example, National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir is seeking to establish his own private militia, to have the power to put Israeli citizens in administrative detention, and to deepen the Shin Bet’s penetration into the lives of Palestinian citizens of Israel. And, in the wake of the events of May 2021, the Israeli army has now drawn up plans to act against Palestinian citizens in the event of a conflict.

Israel’s leaders are realizing that they need to further bend the law to their will, otherwise the identity of the entire area between the river and the sea will never be exclusively Jewish. And unfortunately, the Jewish Zionist left has neither the vision nor the courage to prevent this trend.


Menachem Klein is professor of Political Science at Bar Ilan University. He was an advisor to the Israeli delegation in negotiations with the PLO in 2000 and was one of the leaders of the Geneva Initiative. His new book, Arafat and Abbas: Portraits of Leadership in a State Postponed, was just published by Hurst London and Oxford University Press New York.

Comments (4)

  • David Hawkins says:

    I don’t think it’s so very difficult to understand what is happening now. You just have to read what Professor Ilan Pappe has written about 1948, events that mirror what is happening now. Here in Western Europe we would never ever accept a state that gave the sort of political priority to a religious or ethnic group that Israel gives to Jews. Such a state would be unable to join the EU. In Western Europe a state is supposed to treat all its citizens as equal. We know this often doesn’t happen in practice but at least it is the aim. In Israel it has never even be the aim. Had it been the aim there would be a Palestinian Right of Return to Israel.
    How many “liberal Zionists” support a Palestinian Right of Return to Israel ?
    If you deny that you say ethnic cleansing is OK and that is the root of the problem, today and in 1948.

    0
    0
  • John Hall says:

    This is simple ethnic cleansing. Something the UK (and others) bombed Serbia for, not that many years ago now. Few people now appear willing to call the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians, “ethnic cleansing”. It’s a funny old world!

    0
    0
  • Kuhnberg says:

    “The Palestinians are tolerated only if they assimilate into the landscape, becoming inanimate objects that forgo their collective identity.”

    Wrong. They are not tolerated, period. The mass will is to erase them by one means or another, whether or not they assert their identity. Even the landscape that defines them is being twisted out of shape to accommodate Israel’s myth of itself. Olive groves are being torn down and alien trees planted to disguise all evidence of traditional Palestinian agricultural practices. Water is being diverted. Palestinian common land and homes are being bulldozed and replaced with settlements and rifle-ranges and Israeli theme-parks. Palestinians are expected to surrender to these desecrations without complaint. They have no option other than resistance.

    0
    0
  • Bernard Grant says:

    It’s never ending for the Palestinians, the Nakba hasn’t ceased. The bulldozing of their farms and villages is going to keep going until there is no land for Palestinians to exist. This is ethnic cleansing and nothing is being done to stop it.
    The BBC News had an article on the Jenin violence and murders and framed their sentences to make out that Israel wasn’t the guilty party.

    0
    0

Comments are now closed.