The criminal neglect of Palestinian lives under occupation – and covid-19

JVL Introduction

The author, Dr. Mustapha Barghouthi is a physician who serves on the Palestinian health committee that deals with Covid-19. He is also a former Palestinian minister.

He is suffering from Covid-19.

You can see an interview with him on 5th January on Democracy Now: “Medical Apartheid”: Israeli Vaccine Drive Excludes Millions of Palestinians in Occupied Territories

See our earlier report Horrific discrimination against Palestinians under occupation with regard to COVID-19 vaccines.

Added 14th Jan: See also this fantastic webinar organised by Yachad and the New Israel Fund with Ran Goldstein, Director of Physicians for Human Rights Israel, and leading Israeli human rights lawyer, Michael Sfard, discussing vaccine access and legal responsibilities in the occupied Palestinian territories

This article was originally published by the New York Times on Wed 13 Jan 2021. Read the original here.

Israel’s Vaccination Drive Is Going Great. But We’re Being Sidelined.

The country can’t reach herd immunity without vaccinating Palestinians.

Also: join the discussion on Eventbrite today 13th Janary at 7pm UK time: Vaccine Apartheid? Occupation in the time of COVID-19 (Eventbrite)

RAMALLAH, West Bank — Israel’s plans to inoculate its population against Covid-19 are proceeding briskly. The country has vaccinated a larger share of its population than any other country, and its drive is being praised as an example of an effective vaccination program. But there is a darker side to this success story: Some five million Palestinians under its control are being sidelined.

While Israel has a plan to inoculate all of its citizens in the next few months, it is leaving Palestinians living in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip to fend for themselves.

Gaza and the West Bank are suffering from a serious coronavirus outbreak. There have been more than 165,900 infections and 1,756 deaths in the two territories. More than 1,800 new cases are registered a day. The rate of infection in the two areas is 30 percent among those who are tested, in comparison with 7.4 percent in Israel.

While Israel is now struggling to curtail a new wave of infections, it is on track to vaccinate 25 percent of its population by the end of January and every Israeli by the end of March.

This includes about 600,000 settlers, who, according to international law, are illegally living in the West Bank, but who hold Israeli passports. They will receive the vaccine in the coming days while about three million Palestinians living in the same area will not. Israel has also ordered that vaccines be provided for prison guards, but not for the thousands of Palestinian prisoners.

Granted, Arabs living in Israel proper who hold Israeli citizenship are being vaccinated. But Israel also made a commitment in the Oslo accords to work with the Palestinians to combat epidemics, so it has a moral obligation to supply vaccines in the West Bank and Gaza.

Instead, it has so far dismissed a request by the World Health Organization and the Palestinian Authority, the self-governing body in the West Bank, to provide up to 10,000 vaccine doses for Palestinian frontline workers. Knowing that Israel will not share its vaccine supply anytime soon, Palestinians have to rely on the good will of foreign organizations and companies. But a vaccination program for the West Bank and Gaza will be far slower than the rapid rollout that Israelis are getting.

Covax, a coalition of international health organizations, has pledged to vaccinate Palestinians in the two territories but the vaccines aren’t expected to arrive before the end of February and they would be administered to only 3 percent of people there by April, with a further rollout throughout the year.

The health ministry of the Palestinian Authority has also made arrangements to receive more than two million doses of the Oxford-AstraZeneca and Russia’s Sputnik V vaccines but those are also not expected to arrive soon.

Israel has said that the Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza are responsible for their own health care. It insists that the Palestinian Authority is in charge of the West Bank and that, with the redeployment of Israeli troops from Gaza in 2005, Gaza is also self-ruled.

But the reality is that Israel and its military still essentially have control over the West Bank and Gaza. The Palestinian Authority does not control the borders, crossing, or air space. Indeed, the Palestinian Authority is present in only 38 percent of the West Bank, land that is fragmented by the wall, checkpoints and Israeli settlements. Sixty percent of the West Bank, known as Area C, is off limits to the authority. In Gaza, the crossing, borders, sea and airspace are under Israeli control (aside from one part of Gaza’s southern border that is controlled by Egypt).

As outlined in the Geneva Conventions, an occupying power, which, despite its denial, Israel continues to be, “has the duty of ensuring and maintaining, with the cooperation of national and local authorities, the medical and hospital establishments and services, public health and hygiene in the occupied territory, with particular reference to the adoption and application of the prophylactic and preventive measures necessary to combat the spread of contagious diseases and epidemics.”

The economic and geographic control Israel holds over the territory of the Palestinian Authority has led to great discrepancies and inequities. In 2018, the average expenditure on health care for a Palestinian in the Palestinian territories was a mere $344, compared to $3,324 for an Israeli.

The risk that the health care system will collapse increases daily in the West Bank, and even more in densely populated Gaza, where about two million Palestinians live, mostly in poverty. Until recently, hospital beds there were near capacity. While hospitals in Gaza have received a much-needed influx of oxygen, they are still suffering from shortages of medications and disposable equipment needed to treat Covid-19 patients.

The Israeli government’s decision to make the vaccine available only to Israeli citizens is not just a moral injustice, it is self-defeating. Herd immunity will not be achieved for Israelis without vaccinating Palestinians. There are more than 130,000 Palestinians working in Israel and the settlements, and hundreds of thousands of Israelis travel between Israeli settlements or engage in military activities in the occupied Palestinian territories.

When we received our medical degrees, I and other doctors swore an oath to not discriminate. Medicine and medical care should not treat some patients as less worthy of treatment. Such an approach violates the values and integrity of the medical profession and hurts everyone — including Israelis.


Dr. Mustafa Barghouthi is a medical doctor and a former Palestinian minister and Palestinian Legislative Council member.

Comments (7)

  • steve mitchell says:

    The Labour leadership has abandoned the Palestinians. I read today they will not be pursuing progressive policies in future. We are on the way back to the days of New Labour. In other words there can be no hope for change. I have resigned my membership after over 60 years . My two children have done the same ( without any advice from me).

  • Michel Trainer says:

    As a British Jew I feel ashamed and disgusted. Still struggling whether to leave the Labour party or stay and oppose the leadership.

  • Anne says:

    Which Palestinian aid charity would Dr Barghouthi – or one who has worked with aid agencies there – most recommend ?

  • Taraneh says:

    I have no words to describe the cruelty and the racism that the Israel is treating the Palestinians. And I am so ashamed of labour leader to keep silence on this artocity.

  • David Townsend says:

    Steve Mitchell: solidarity!

  • David Aldred says:

    I am not Jewish, yet I too feel ashamed – as a human being: I am (still) a Labour member and I ask, how can people look the other way, pass their fellow human in the street when that person is in need? And even on a purely selfish level, how can one look in the bathroom mirror without blinking, when one’s own household is healthy whilst the family next-door suffers?

  • George Wilmers says:

    My advice to Michel Trainer is to stay in the Labour Party and to publicly denounce the inhuman policies of the leadership until he gets thrown out as a “fringe Jew”, to use the terminology of the Board of Deputies. That is my policy and I am convinced that at present it is the most effective strategy that an individual Jewish socialist can take.

    The most important thing is NEVER to allow oneself to self-censor on account of one’s membership of the LP. The anonymous inquisitors of the LP governance and legal unit tried to investigate me once on spurious accusations of antisemitism and were obliged to crawl back into their hovel. I expect a new attack by these charlatans at any moment, but I care not. If I am expelled, I will continue to support and collaborate with socialists both within and outside the LP, but my freedom to denounce and campaign against the bigots and unprincipled opportunists within the party will only be increased, because I will no longer be subject to party rules. The irony of the Labour leadership’s repression of freedom of expression within CLP’s is that it is counterproductive: the more that CLP’s begin to resemble totalitarian shell structures, the more political discourse migrates to local social media groups which include socialists both within and outside the LP.

    Incidentally, being called a “fringe Jew” by the BOD should be regarded as a tremendous compliment. Almost all the major Jewish icons of universal human culture from Spinoza, Marx and Freud to Einstein, Bohr and Chomsky were “fringe Jews” who will be honoured long after the Zionist cult has vanished from consciousness, a historical anomaly studied perhaps by specialist historians in the same manner as the bizarre 17th century messianic cult of Sabbatai Zevi.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Read our full comment policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.