Extra! Gazans are responsible for their own deaths.
JVL Introduction
IN an opinion piece in Haaretz last month Gideon Levy describes a predominant mood in Israel – blaming the people of Gaza for their own suffering.
For him, respected journalist Ben Caspit epitomises the Israeli centre.
In response to an invitation to look at CNN footage from Gaza Caspit’s answer was simple: “Why should we look? They earned their hell honestly; I don’t have an ounce of sympathy.”
Post October 7, anything goes. One can blame thouands of children and babies for their own deaths: “Let their limbs be amputated, let the children die, let all Gazans expire, let them suffocate in hell, it’s not our business. They are responsible for their disaster, only them.”
These are dangerous thoughts says Levy. “Humaneness is forbidden, we are Israeli.”
RK
This article was originally published by Haaretz on Sun 17 Dec 2023. Read the original here.
In Israel, 20,000 Gazans are responsible for their own deaths. I've never been so ashamed
Journalist Ben Caspit epitomizes the Israeli center. He lives in Hod Hasharon and co-hosts a radio talk show with journalist Yinon Magal, who is on the extreme right. Caspit, supposedly, is not. He is a well-connected journalist, highly respected and successful.
Over the weekend, the executive director of the anti-occupation group Breaking the Silence wrote on X: “Don’t look away. A CNN correspondent entered the southern Gaza Strip and opened a ‘window on the hell’ of Gaza.”
This is what Caspit, a moderate and decent person in his own eyes, had to say in response: “Why should we look? They earned their hell honestly; I don’t have an ounce of sympathy.” Caspit, as usual, is the mouthpiece of Israel’s mainstream.
Eight thousand children are to blame for their own deaths; 20,000 people are responsible for being killed; 2 million people caused their own uprooting. This is how a rich person always talks about the poor, the successful person about the less fortunate, the healthy person about the disabled, the strong about the weak, the Ashkenazi about Mizrahi Jews: They are to blame for their victimhood.
In post-October 7 Israel, one can blame 10,000 children and babies for their own deaths without Israel having even a hint of responsibility and culpability. In post-October 7 Israel, one can feel blameless only because Hamas started committing atrocities first.
A country lies in ruins and all its residents are in hell, and the generator of this hell bears no guilt, not even a tiny bit, not even together with Hamas’ guilt. The epitome of the Israeli center doesn’t even have an ounce of sympathy for the amputee children shown in the courageous, horrific report of Clarissa Ward from a Rafah hospital.
Let their limbs be amputated, let the children die, let all Gazans expire, let them suffocate in hell, it’s not our business. They are responsible for their disaster, only them. Caspit is on to something here – the victim is responsible for his victimhood.
Putting aside the issue of guilt and responsibility – these are all on Hamas, not at all on Israel, whose soldiers and pilots are running wild and unbridled in Gaza – we have no hand in it, the main thing is that we feel no guilt for any of it.
Putting that aside for a moment, one needs an unbelievable degree of obtuseness, cruelty, and even barbarity to not feel at least some empathy for children dying on hospital floors, to a father crying over the body of his child, to an infant covered in the dust of his bombed house, looking in vain for someone in the world, for people living for two months in terror, in despair and with nothing left in their lives; for the hungry, the sick, the disabled and the dispossessed of the Gaza Strip.
Even empathy is prohibited in the eyes of Caspit and his ilk, lest a dangerous, forbidden thought creep in – that it is human beings who live in Gaza. This is something Israelis cannot cope with.
This is a crossing of a dangerous line which may be followed by thoughts that are alien to Israelis, regarding how far it is permissible to go for a just cause; what is permissible, and, mainly, what is prohibited under any circumstances.
There are things that are forbidden under any circumstances. The killing of 8,000 children in two months, for example. Caspit and his folks only want to cheer the heroic army without seeing its handiwork.
Humaneness is forbidden, we are Israeli. When an earthquake happens anywhere on the globe, we’ll send aid and be proud of ourselves, but mass killing in Gaza is not our business. That’s the way Israel’s morality works. It’s meant to allow Caspit, not just Magal, to feel good about themselves about Gaza.
At an international conference held last weekend in Istanbul, I said, among other things, that never have I been so ashamed to be Israeli as I have been in viewing pictures from Gaza. These words were posted on a popular Israeli entertainment website. Over the weekend, I received hundreds (perhaps thousands by now) of abusive calls and text messages. One can often learn about a society through its sewers. Together we will win, goes the current slogan.
However, the distance between the sewage flowing my way and the ostensibly respectable words of Caspit is smaller than one imagines. There is no difference between the hatred of Arabs and their dehumanization, as expressed in the vulgar, inarticulate language of my callers, and the well-formulated words of Caspit.
Both the lower and higher Israel have lost their human image. This is reason enough to be ashamed of being Israeli.
Just how easily the Israeli Army and Air Force have descended into utter barbarity is shocking. Don’t any of their senior commanders have a shred of common humanity?
Why would Gideon L (of all people) be ‘*ashamed*’ because of Israel’s crimes? He’s not guilty of committing them, indeed he’s done more than most to expose them.
I’ve sometimes heard fellow-Jews say they’re ‘ashamed to be Jewish’ but only because of Israeli wrongdoing. Is the shame proportional to the strength of their identification with the State, as if accepting Israel’s rendering them complicit in its crimes because ‘it acts in the name of Jews everywhere’? But they haven’t committed the crimes either.
So innocent people somehow feel ashamed: some kind of mix comprising personal identity, shame, guilt and empathy or its lack. People often talk of shame and guilt as if they’re interchangeable, yet there’s a big difference between them.
In their 2002 book, ‘Shame and Guilt’, psychologists June Tangney & Ronda Dearing find empirical evidence for Helen Block Lewis’s 1971 conceptualisation; the difference between self, as in ‘*I* did that horrible thing’ (shame) versus behaviour, as in ‘I *did* that horrible *thing*’ (guilt): shame being that acutely painful emotion of shrinking worthlessness accompanied by a picture of how one will appear to others plus a wish to escape and hide; guilt, for Lewis, being typically less painful or devastating, because the focus is on ‘a particular behaviour, somewhat apart from the self’ and not affecting one’s core identity or self-concept.
We may condemn Israelis for their manifold wickednesses even when, through deficits of empathy, they can feel no guilt themselves. Through some variety of ‘meaning maintenance model’ (‘They’re animals, not fellow-humans so what we did was permitted’) they repress the voice of conscience before they even hear it. As for shame, we didn’t do a horrible thing, and anyway it isn’t just me, my ego, it’s all of us together, Israeli esprit de corps intact. Malignant pathological group narcissism preserved.
The ‘cure’ for diaspora Jews’ who feel shame is, ‘Get your Jewish identity from traditions that aren’t Zionism’.
What the mindset is of someone’s who can say that innocent children including babies deserve to die and be mutilated by Bombs and Missiles, because they brought it on themselves is staggering but he’s not alone in his views of Palestinians.
If you’re on Twitter/X people say the most heinous things about what Palestinians in Gaza deserve.
Every chance I get to reply to these people, I reply with these same comments, (they are the maximum number of words you’re allowed, so it’s short).
“They didn’t rape women or mutilate babies, it was Lies. They’ve had 75 years of Nakba, Murders, Beatings and Land theft, 2.3m living in the World’s Largest Concentration Camp in Gaza, their Water and Power being turned off to make life miserable!! They call Hamas the Terrorists”!
As this is all about Gaza, I want to point out that reports are being posted that Palestinians are being killed in the West Bank as well. As far as the Israeli Authorities are concerned, all Palestinians are guilty and should be treated as such.
Israel is not losing respect, it has lost respect around the World, how can it be recovered?