JVL Introduction

On 21st November, the Austrian Presidency of the Council of the EU is organising what is billed as a “High Level Conference ‘Europe beyond anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism – securing Jewish life in Europe’”.

It’s programme asserts as fact that : “Very often, anti‑Semitism is expressed through exaggerated and disproportionate criticism of the state of Israel. The demonisation of Jews and the Jewish state in some parts of European society represents the newest manifestation of the oldest hatred.” It is clearly designed to protect that state of Israel against criticism.

Here 35 Israeli academics and artists warn against equating antisemitism with anti-Zionism.

This posting has been updated [20 Nov, 16.30] with the full text of the letter and list of signatories.


Israeli Academics and Artists Warn Against Equating anti-Zionism With anti-Semitism

Their open letter ahead of a conference in Vienna advises against giving Israel immunity for ‘grave and widespread violations of human rights and international law’

Ofer Aderet, Ha’aretz
20 November 2018


An open letter [see full text and list of signatories below] from 35 prominent Israelis, including Jewish-history scholars and Israel Prize laureates, was published Tuesday in the Austrian media calling for a distinction between legitimate criticism of Israel, “harsh as it may be,” and anti-Semitism.

The letter was released before an international gathering in Vienna on anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism in Europe.

The event this week, “Europe beyond anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism: Securing Jewish life in Europe,” is being held under the auspices of Austrian Chancellor Sebastian Kurz. His Israeli counterpart, Benjamin Netanyahu, had been due to take part but stayed in Israel to deal with the crisis in his coalition government.

“We fully embrace and support the [European Union’s] uncompromising fight against anti-Semitism. The rise of anti-Semitism worries us. As we know from history, it has often signaled future disasters to all mankind,” the letter states.

“However, the EU also stands for human rights and has to protect them as forcefully as it fights anti-Semitism. This fight against anti-Semitism should not be instrumentalized to suppress legitimate criticism of Israel’s occupation and severe violations of Palestinian human rights.”

The signatories accuse Netanyahu of suggesting an equivalence between anti-Israel criticism and anti-Semitism. The official declaration by the conference also notes that anti-Semitism is often expressed through disproportionate criticism of Israel, but the letter warns that such an approach could “afford Israel immunity against criticism for grave and widespread violations of human rights and international law.”

The signatories object to the declaration’s alleged “identifying” of anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism. “Zionism, like all other modern Jewish movements in the 20th century, was harshly opposed by many Jews, as well as by non-Jews who were not anti-Semitic,” they write. “Many victims of the Holocaust opposed Zionism. On the other hand, many anti-Semites supported Zionism. It is nonsensical and inappropriate to identify anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism.”

Among the signatories are Moshe Zimmerman, an emeritus professor at Hebrew University and a former director of the university’s Koebner Center for German History; Zeev Sternhell, a Hebrew University emeritus professor in political science and a current Haaretz columnist; sculptor Dani Karavan; Miki Kratsman, a former chairman of the photography department at the Bezalel Academy of Arts and Design; Jose Brunner, an emeritus professor at Tel Aviv University and a former director of the Minerva Institute for German History; Alon Confino, a professor of Holocaust Studies at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst; and graphic designer David Tartakover.


To Europe We Say: Don’t conflate criticism of Israel with anti-Semitism

20 November 2018

In the context of its EU Presidency, the Austrian government will hold a high-level conference on November 21st, titled “Europe Beyond Anti-Semitism and Anti-Zionism – Securing Jewish Life in Europe.”

We fully embrace and support the EU’s uncompromising fight against anti-Semitism. The rise of anti- Semitism worries us. As we know from history, it has often signaled future disasters to all mankind. The rise of anti-Semitism constitutes a real threat and should be a major concern in contemporary European politics.

However, the EU also stands for human rights and has to protect them as forcefully as it fights anti- Semitism. This fight against anti-Semitism should not be instrumentalized to suppress legitimate criticism of Israel’s occupation and severe violations of Palestinian human rights.

Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu was to address the conference in Austria, until he cancelled to stabilize his government. He has worked hard to conflate criticism of the state of Israel with anti- Semitism.

To our great concern, we see this conflation also in the official announcement of the conference by the Austrian government. It says: “Very often, anti-Semitism is expressed through exaggerated and disproportionate criticism of the state of Israel.”

These words echo the anti-Semitism definition of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA). Several examples of contemporary anti-Semitism attached to this definition, relate to harsh critique of Israel. As a result, the definition can be dangerously instrumentalized to afford Israel immunity against criticism for grave and wide-spread violations of human rights and international law – criticism which is considered legitimate when directed at other countries. This has a chilling effect on any critique of Israel.

Moreover, the conference announcement identifies anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism. However, Zionism, like all other modern Jewish movements in the 20th century, was harshly opposed by many Jews, as well as by non-Jews who were not anti-Semitic. Many victims of the Holocaust opposed Zionism. On the other hand, many anti-Semites supported Zionism. It is nonsensical and inappropriate to identify anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism.

We must also not forget that the state of Israel has been an occupying power for more than 50 years. Millions of Palestinians under occupation lack basic rights, freedom and dignity. As the Israeli occupation is now transforming into annexation, it is essential, more than ever, that Europe rejects efforts to restrict free speech and to silence criticism of Israel on the false ground of equating it with anti-Semitism.

Europe also needs to do so for the credibility and effectiveness of its fight against anti-Semitism. Extending this fight to protect the state of Israel from criticism feeds misconceptions that Jews equal Israel – and are thus responsible for what Israel does.

As Israeli scholars, most of whom research and teach Jewish history, we say to Europe:

Relentlessly fight anti-Semitism to protect Jewish life in Europe, and allow it to thrive. Do so while maintaining a clear distinction between criticism of the state of Israel, harsh as it may be, and anti-Semitism. Don’t mix anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism. And preserve free speech for those who reject the Israeli occupation and insist that it ends.

Signed by

Professor Gadi Algazi, Department of History, Tel Aviv University.

Dr. Yael Berda, Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

Professor Jose Brunner (emeritus), Cohn Institute for the History and Philosophy of Science and Ideas, and Buchmann Faculty of Law, Tel Aviv University. Former director of the Minerva Institute for German History and founding academic supervisor of Israel’s first legal clinic for the rights of Holocaust survivors, Tel Aviv University.

Professor Alon Confino, Pen Tishkach Chair of Holocaust Studies, University of Massachusetts Amherst.

Professor Arie M. Dubnov, Max Ticktin Chair of Israel Studies, Department of History, George Washington University.

Professor Rachel Elior, John and Golda Cohen Professor of Jewish Philosophy and Jewish Mystical Thought, Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

Professor David Enoch, Rodney Blackman Chair in the Philosophy of Law, Faculty of Law, Philosophy Department, Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

Dr. Yuval Eylon, Senior Lecturer in Philosophy and Ideas, Tel Aviv University, Department of History, Philosophy and Judaic Studies, Open University of Israel.

Professor Gideon Freudenthal (emeritus), Cohn Institute for the History and Philosophy of Science Studies and Ideas

Dr. Amos Goldberg, former Chair Department of Jewish History and Contemporary Jewry, Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

Professor David Harel, Weizmann Institute of Science; Vice-President of the Israel Academy of Sciences and Humanities; Israel Prize recipient (2004); EMET Prize recipient (2010).

Professor Hannan Hever, Department of Comparative Literature and the Judaic Studies Program, Yale University.

Professor Eva Illouz, Department of Sociology, Hebrew University Jerusalem; former president of Bezalel Academy of Art and Design, Jerusalem.

Daniel Karavan, sculptor, creator of the Memorial to Sinti and Roma Victims of National Socialism in Berlin (2012) and the Way of Human Rights at Germanisches Nationalmuseum in Nuremberg (1989-93); Israel Prize recipient (1977).

Professor Hannah Kasher (emerita), Department of Jewish Thought, Bar-Ilan University.

Professor Michael Keren (emeritus), Department of Economics, Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

Professor Yehoshua Kolodny (emeritus), Institute of Earth Sciences, Hebrew University of Jerusalem; Israel Prize recipient (2010).

Miki Kratsman, former Head of Photography Department at Bezalel Academy of Arts and Design; EMET Prize recipient (2011).

Nitzan Lebovic, Associate Professor, Apter Chair of Holocaust Studies and Ethical Values, Lehigh University

Alex Levac, Israel Prize recipient (2005).

Dr. Anat Matar, Department of Philosophy, Tel Aviv University.

Professor Paul Mendes-Flohr (emeritus), Department of Jewish Thought, Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

Professor Jacob Metzer (emeritus), former president of the Open University Israel; Alexander Brody Professor of Economic History, Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

Michal Naaman, artist, Israel Prize recipient (2014).

Professor Yehuda Judd Ne’eman (emeritus), Faculty of Arts, Tel Aviv University; Israel Prize recipient (2009).

Professor Dalia Ofer (emerita), Max and Rita Haber Professor of Contemporary Jewry and Holocaust Studies, Avraham Harman Institute of Contemporary Jewry, Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

Professor Ishay Rosen-Zvi, Head Talmud and Late Antiquity section, Department of Jewish Philosophy, Tel Aviv University.

Professor David Shulman (emeritus), Department of Asian Studies, Hebrew University of Jerusalem; EMET Prize recipient (2010); Israel Prize recipient (2016).

Dr. Dmitry Shumsky, Department of Jewish History and Contemporary Jewry, former Director Bernard Cherrick Center for the Study of the Zionism, the Yishuv and the State of Israel, Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

Professor Zeev Sternhell (emeritus), Department of Political Science, Hebrew University of Jerusalem; Israel Prize recipient (2008).

Professor David Tartakover, Israel Prize recipient (2002).

Professor Idith Zertal, Hebrew University of Jerusalem; Institute for Jewish Studies University of Basel; author of ‘Israel’s Holocaust and the Politics of Nationhood’.

Professor Moshe Zimmerman (emeritus), former Director Koebner Center for German History, Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

Professor Moshe Zuckermann (emeritus), Cohn Institute for the History and Philosophy of Science and Ideas, Tel Aviv University.