Anti-Catholic sentiment has no place in the Labour leadership contest

JVL Introduction

Candidates should be judged on their merits and their views assessed on the basis of what they say about them, not what is read into them because of their religious affiliation.

MPs Mike Kane and Conor McGinn attack an anti-Catholic sentiment which they argue lies close to the surface, and which they believe can damage Labour’s credibility among millions of voters.

This article was originally published by PoliticsHome on Sat 18 Jan 2020. Read the original here.

Mike Kane and Conor McGinn: Anti-Catholic sentiment has no place in the Labour leadership contest

To tweak a famous quote from the late, great Harold Wilson: The Labour Party owes more to Catholicism than Communism.

For over one hundred years Catholics across the United Kingdom have formed the backbone of Labour’s vote.

The formation of the party itself takes its roots from Catholicism through the actions of Cardinal Manning. In August 1889 London’s dock workers went on strike, in a protest which destabilised the country. Manning was struck by the peaceful nature of the protest and actively sought resolution. Within a month his efforts ensured the dockers’ demands were largely met, and the strike ended.

This was a devout Catholic leader, inspired by his faith to improve working conditions for some of the most vulnerable in Victorian society. A year later, taking inspiration from this, the Labour Party was founded.

Fast-forward just over 130 years and times have changed. Catholics have abandoned what was once considered their political home, especially in Scotland where over half have given their vote to the SNP.

The reasons for this are many and have been scrutinised in other places, but ultimately as Catholic Labour MPs we take our share of the responsibility for not showing Catholic voters they had a place in our party. That’s why just over two years ago we formed Catholics for Labour. To show Catholics that they belong in the Labour movement and to give them the confidence to speak with pride about how their faith and membership are inextricably linked.

We are Labour because of our Catholic values, not despite them. And we were making progress. Establishing an annual Mass at our party conference, hosting policy seminars and building a strong online following.

But in the past few days that progress has stalled. It began with a sensationalised article regarding Rebecca Long-Bailey’s views on abortion and ended with age-old anti-Catholic bigotry – claims that all Catholics’ first-loyalty is to Rome. Smears that have been used to marginalise and persecute Catholics in this country and elsewhere for centuries.

Labour’s Catholic supporters, members and MPs are a pretty diverse bunch – a broad church if you like. We disagree and hold opposing views on many issues, including abortion and equal marriage. But those views are our own, not the Pope’s.

To be clear, there are no vested interests here. Neither of us have nominated Rebecca for the leadership or even backed the same candidate (perhaps the Vatican lost our number?). But we will not stand idle while her faith is being used to smear her or tolerate blatant sectarianism and anti-Catholic tropes.

What’s most deflating of all is that this row has erupted in the crucible of a leadership election where Labour must seek to become an inclusive movement once again if it is serious about challenging at the next general election and beyond. Alienating the Catholic vote is not the way to do this.

We started this piece with our take on a famous quote, so let’s finish with one we don’t need to be clever with. Lyndon B Johnson once famously said that the first rule of politics is to know how to count. The bottom line here is that there are millions of Catholics in the UK and Labour should ignore them at their peril.

* Conor McGinn MP and Mike Kane MP, founding members of Catholics for Labour

Comments (1)

  • RH says:

    I have absolutely no problem with the premise of this article. There is a strong tradition of practising Catholics active in the Labour Party, and it has never been an issue.

    But the point is that a few ill-chosen or prejudicial remarks don’t undermine that fact, and I groan at yet another cultural/religious group claiming exceptional discrimination whilst the roof of the underpinning of progressive politics is falling in.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Read our full comment policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.